| Platinum | Russ' Restaurant |
| Gold | Westside Social |
| Silver | Choo Choo Grill |
| Bronze | Kitchen 67 |
| Top Pick | Anna's House - Plainfield |
| Top Pick | Smokey Bones Grand Rapids |
| Top Pick | The Candied Yam |
| Top Pick | Timbers Inn Restaurant & Tavern |
| Top Pick | Z's Bar & Restaurant |