| Platinum | Steenstra's Royal Dutch Bakery |
| Gold | The Salted Cupcake |
| Silver | Rise Bakery |
| Bronze | Sandy's Donuts |
| Top Pick | Bostwick Bakery |
| Top Pick | Field & Fire Cafe |
| Top Pick | Just Enjoy |
| Top Pick | Nantucket Baking Co |
| Top Pick | Queen of Sweets |
| Top Pick | Wealthy Street Bakery |