| Platinum | Love's Ice Cream |
| Platinum | Tastefull Vegan |
| Gold | Frosty Boy |
| Silver | Sundaes in The Park |
| Bronze | Fruition Acai & Juice Bar |
| Top Pick | Bumblebee Ice Cream |
| Top Pick | Dewinters Double Dip |
| Top Pick | Double Dip Depot |
| Top Pick | Furniture City Creamery |
| Top Pick | Too Tall's |