| Platinum | Brick Road Pizza Co |
| Gold | Two Beards Deli |
| Silver | Boardwalk Subs |
| Bronze | Jimmy John's |
| Top Pick | Anna's House |
| Top Pick | Electric Cheetah |
| Top Pick | Fresh Coast Kitchen |
| Top Pick | Pita House |
| Top Pick | Red Hot Inn Restaurants |
| Top Pick | Rinaldi Pizza & Sub Shop |