| Platinum | Andiamo's Pizza |
| Gold | Buddy's Pizza |
| Silver | The Mitten Brewing Company |
| Bronze | Peppinos Pizza |
| Top Pick | Amore Trattoria Italiana |
| Top Pick | Fratelli's |
| Top Pick | Peppinos Sports Grille & Pizzeria |
| Top Pick | Russo Italian Restaurant + Market |
| Top Pick | The Old Goat |
| Top Pick | Vitale's Pizza |