| Platinum | Uptown Cheapskate |
| Gold | Rewind |
| Silver | New 2 You Shoppe |
| Bronze | The Elevated Market |
| Top Pick | Decaydence Vintage |
| Top Pick | Gild The Lily |
| Top Pick | Legacy Thrift |
| Top Pick | Mel Trotter Stores |
| Top Pick | Rock Paper Scissors |
| Top Pick | Village Kids Consignment Boutique |